‘The goverment wants to dismantle the peace agreement’: former foreign minister Cristo

Juan Fernando Cristo has had a frontrow seat on peacebuilding in Colombia. He was elected to the senate in 1998 and, under then-president Juan Manuel Santos, appointed interior minister in 2014. In this role, he was a lead government negotiator in the talks with the FARC guerrilla movement that resulted in the 2016 peace agreement. He served as interior minister a second time under President Gustavo Petro in 2024.

In an exclusive interview, JFC spoke to Dr Cristo about the election of a far-right government, the implications for the peace process and why land reform remains fundamental to peace in Colombia.

>>>>>

How do you view the new government’s policies towards the peace agreement?

I don’t think it’s a secret – the president himself said it – that the government is an enemy of the peace agreement. That’s very clear. The political will to implement the agreement does not exist.

But the agreement is protected by the constitution and international commitments within which the government has to operate. But the decisions it has taken on the peace agreement are signs of animosity more telling than words. The 2027 national budget has substantially cut funding for the peace agreement as they move to dismantle the progress achieved in recent years. The government cut 20% of the budget for the JEP transitional justice court. It has not appointed a new peace commissioner, nor a director of the implementation unit. These entities are headless.

At the United Nations Security Council, where the UK plays an important role, they have asked to reduce the UN Verification Mission’s role to a minimum focus on reintegration and security. The government’s objective is to dismantle the agreement through the back door because they can’t do it through the front door.

Foreign Minister Omar Bula said there has been no peace since 2016, implying the agreement has failed. How do you respond to this assessment?

The government doesn’t believe in the peace agreement or the need for implementation in the territories. The foreign minister is childish to think that signing the agreement meant conflict would end the next day. This is impossible. But when one looks at the statistics for violence in Colombia, there have been impressive results in terms of reducing violence. In terms of kidnappings, homicides, deaths of soldiers and police, or the pacification of many regions, the agreement has had a very positive impact.

While there has been transformation in some territories, it’s less than we’d hoped for. We still need to move forward a lot. But the reduction of violence in Colombia is shown by the numbers, even though it persists in regions where the agreement has not been implemented. The foreign minister attributed all the deaths in Colombia to conflict, including traffic accidents, domestic violence and street violence. This aims to generate the impression that the agreement has been a failure. It’s a false narrative. The homicide rate in Colombia has decreased when you compare 2015 with 2026. However, the presence of dissident groups and failures to implement the agreement has unfortunately caused damage in regions such as Catatumbo, Cauca and Nariño.

Comprehensive rural reform is a fundamental pillar of the agreement. Could you explain your reaction to the government’s proposal to remove oversight of rural reform from the UN Mission’s mandate?

The armed conflict in Colombia arose 60 years ago over land and this issue is still alive despite some right-wing analysts insisting there’s no longer a problem due to Colombia’s urban population. The origin of violence in Colombia is the dispute over land. Violence dispossessed many people from their lands. There is a 15-year-old policy of land restitution, but the state has not fulfilled this. Comprehensive rural reform, or agrarian reform, is the first point of the peace agreement. It was not agreed to benefit the former FARC combatants, but for more than 10 million Colombian peasants who still live in rural areas, who are not FARC members and who are victims of conflict. The progress achieved under the Petro government was very important, but it’s still insufficient for the size of the challenge.

By asking the UN to exclude rural reform from its verification, the government is sending a message that it doesn’t want international oversight as, they claim, it is a domestic issue. Without oversight, they will start dismantling what was agreed. The government’s discourse leaves no room for equivocation. They are not friends of formalisation of rural property or distribution of land. It’s very bad news for the countryside and campesinos.

The new Minister of Agriculture’s first statement to congress said that discussion of campesino issues had to end. There was no reason for that. They don’t think there’s a problem of land distribution even though Colombia has perhaps the world’s highest index of land concentration. They favour large industrial agriculture projects so campesino rights are not important other than their status as farmworkers. This is a longstanding vision of the Colombian countryside.

There were various past attempts at agrarian reform. In 1936, the Liberal president, Alfonso López Pumarejo, tried to carry out agrarian reform but was blocked by the same interests as today. In the 1960s, another Liberal president, Carlos Lleras Restrepo, tried again and the landowners again blocked it. Now, President Petro’s government moved ahead with the constitutional creation of the agrarian jurisdiction, but this is still pending. The new government will not take it forwards. They will not complete land formalisation processes. There will be no more land purchased for small-scale farmers, nor any investment in formalisation of land titles.

I think the UN will agree to exclude rural reform from its verification mandate. It is very difficult to reject a request from a country’s government. I’m not very optimistic about that. It seems to me that the UN is resigned to this, they don’t want to openly fight with the government, which also has the United States’ support.

You helped create the Victims’ Law of 2011. How do think new government policies will impact victims’ rights?

The Victims’ Law was passed before the peace agreement with the FARC. It obliges the Colombian State to provide reparations to conflict victims. It coordinates care for victims and restitution of land to displaced campesinos. So far, there’s no sign of any policy around it, neither good nor bad. But what’s clear is that the 2027 budget will significantly cut state capacity to provide comprehensive reparations to victims.

What is your response to the new ‘anti-terrorism statute’ that the government recently submitted? What are its implications for the peace process?

The government has not yet presented the bill to congress. But we have seen drafts that are very bad, very undemocratic. What we know is that it’s very dangerous for Colombian democracy, the political opposition and social movements. The Supreme Court of Justice and civil society organisations have expressed concerns. I’d say we need to wait for the government to present the text in congress. We agree with the need to equip the Colombian State with the strongest legal instruments to combat narco-terrorism and illegal groups. We must use all institutional capacities, always within the framework of respect for human rights, freedoms and the 1991 Constitution.

If the government proposes a democratic dialogue, all political sectors in Colombia must be open to discussing it – but not a statute that curtails freedoms and the rights of Colombians. This would not be a statute against terrorists, but a statute against the political opposition. As the opposition in Colombia, we must be willing to participate in a discussion about the need for an anti-terrorist statute and its content. We can’t simply reject that discussion.

Justice for Colombia builds international support for peace, human rights, trade unionism and social rights. How important is the role of the international community?

The government is showing signs of authoritarianism, democratic cuts and restrictions of people’s freedoms and rights. We see this in its attitudes towards social protest, trade unions, young people, women, art and culture. The role of the international community is particularly important on two essential fronts. Firstly, support for implementation of the Peace Agreement – we can’t give up on this as it’s fundamental for the country. The existence of the UN Verification Mission and the Security Council are fundamental to guarantee the right to peace, reconciliation and victims’ rights in Colombia.

Secondly, it’s very important to ensure strict respect for human rights. Thanks to the peace agreement, increased civilian influence in the armed forces and the role of organisations like Justice for Colombia, we’ve made a lot of progress around human rights. There now exists a culture of respect for human rights in the military and police. We cannot go backwards on that. It would be very negative for the country if we ended up going back 20 years in terms of human rights.

The fight against drug trafficking and terrorism is compatible with respect for human rights. Unfortunately, sectors of the Colombian right argue that for the fight against terrorism to be effective, we have to disregard international standards of human rights. That cannot be acceptable in a democracy.